Community Voices

Attention homeowners: A cautionary experience

Our home has its original cast-iron main sewer line beneath the house. In late September 2026, one of our bathrooms became clogged. This had happened before, and one plumber had cleared it in a single visit. Unfortunately, our usual plumber could not come until Monday, and this was a Thursday. Searching online, I found a plumbing company with a high rating and a low promotional price for clearing a clogged drain. I called the company.

While I was giving the usual information, I was asked an unusual question: whether I was the homeowner. I hired the company, and two plumbers arrived in about 45 minutes. This was also unusual, because the job had previously required only one plumber. When I showed them the bathroom with the clogged toilet, the plumbers asked whether the shower was backing up, because there was water in the bottom of it. The water was left from the house cleaners, who had used it to clean the shower, and it had not drained.

The plumbers kept chatting with me instead of getting to work. When one finally started on the toilet, he worked at it vigorously and then said he could not clear it. The other asked whether there was a cleanout. I showed them the one on the same side of the house as the bathroom. When it was opened, water drained out. They then put a camera into the pipe. Looking at the image, one plumber said a lighter area showed a problem. I could not tell what I was looking at.

Next, they asked whether there was a crawl space. I said yes and opened the trapdoor. One plumber went in and, using his phone’s light, said the crawl space was very wet. The impression he created was that the main line had holes in it and was unsafe to use. When he came out, he offered to patch the damaged section for $2,200. I replied that because the system was old, patching it would be a waste of money, since it needed to be replaced. The plumbers then said replacing the system would cost $16,000 to $18,000. I told them that for a project that big, I always get three estimates.

They said the owner might offer a discount, then called the owner, who offered 15% off, bringing the price to just under $16,000. I insisted I needed three estimates. They kept pressuring me in various ways. I told them I would give them an answer the next day. I also mentioned that I would stay at a motel, since the main line appeared unsafe to use.

The next morning, I contacted The End Result, a homeowner referral service I always use. They gave me the names of three plumbers, and one of them came out around noon. By then, the toilet had drained. He flushed it and found no problem. I asked him to check around the cleanout for puddles, which the first plumbers had led me to expect. He shone a strong light around the main sewer line and found no wet spots. Then he went into the crawl space and, again using his light, said it was completely dry. The only moisture was some dripping at pipe joints, not enough to form puddles or wet spots. Because there had been a blockage and the main line was old, he suggested cleaning out the entire line to remove some of the buildup on the cast-iron pipes until I was ready to replace it. I agreed.

Later, one of the first two plumbers called to ask whether I would accept their bid. I said I would not hire them because they had misled me. He countered that they had cleared the line and had asked me to flush the toilet before they left, but that I had said I was going to a motel for the night. Because their visit to my home was not recorded, what they said there could be denied or reframed. The phone call on the company line, however, was recorded. Further conversation was pointless. I had to block several more attempts by the company to contact me and mark its emails as spam.

Watch for these warning signs: a low promotional price for a service, being asked whether you are the homeowner, two workers showing up for a one-person job, chatting instead of working and pressure to commit to the work immediately. Always get at least a second estimate before hiring someone for a major repair, and never hire under pressure. You can also search online for the typical price range of a specific repair.


Discover more from Fullerton Observer

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

1 reply »

  1. Wow – how awful – thanks for sharing that experience. There is an excellent local plumber (Patrick Seale of Seale Plumbing) who occasionally has an ad in the Observer who we have used for years and recommend for his high skills and honesty.

    Also years ago I had a similar experience with an extermination company who went into the attic and declared I needed $6000 of work to shore up holes in the screens to prevent rats from getting in. He showed me photos of the damage – and said there were nests and rat droppings everywhere – but I went up there myself and saw nothing of what he described- the photos were not of my attic.

    I sent him away and put a rat trap up there just in case – but never caught anything. I don’t know what the noise we heard earlier was but it didn’t come back and there was no serious rat infestation as he claimed.

Engage in civil discussion

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.