Health

Fullerton Tobacco Ordinance Leaves Out Several Proposed Restrictions

Fullerton’s proposed tobacco retail licensing ordinance includes new requirements for tobacco retailers, but it does not incorporate several additional restrictions recommended by America On Track, the nonprofit organization that worked with the city on tobacco prevention.

A November 17 City Council agenda report identifies seven policy recommendations that were not included in the proposed ordinance. The omissions involve tobacco sales in pharmacies, coupons and discounts, additional compliance inspections, minimum package sizes, larger separation distances, flavored tobacco exemptions and online or delivery sales.

The distinctions are significant because the ordinance is intended to strengthen local oversight of tobacco retailers, but its provisions do not address every sales practice or product category identified during the development process.

Seven recommendations left out

According to the Community and Economic Development Department’s report, the following recommendations were not incorporated:

1. Prohibiting tobacco sales in pharmacies

The proposed ordinance does not prohibit pharmacies from selling tobacco products. Staff said implementing this restriction would require an amendment and a public hearing process.

2. Prohibiting coupons and discounts

The ordinance does not prohibit retailers from offering tobacco coupons or discounts. The report identifies enforcement through Police Department retail inspections as a possible implementation responsibility.

3. Requiring at least two compliance checks annually

The proposed ordinance requires at least one annual compliance inspection for each retailer, rather than the recommended minimum of two.

Staff noted that additional inspections would increase Police Department costs and could increase annual licensing fees.

4. Increasing separation distances to 1,000 feet

America On Track recommended increasing the proposed separation distances to 1,000 feet.

The ordinance retains the smaller distances: 500 feet from specified sensitive uses, including schools, parks, child care centers and tutoring centers, and 250 feet between tobacco retail stores.

The restrictions apply to new tobacco retail stores, not existing businesses.

5. Removing all flavored tobacco exemptions

The proposed ordinance does not establish a prohibition without exemptions.

It allows flavored shisha at hookah retailers serving customers 21 and older, premium cigars and loose-leaf tobacco.

America On Track recommended eliminating those exemptions from the flavored tobacco definition.

6. Prohibiting minimum package-size exceptions

The proposed ordinance does not establish a minimum package-size requirement for tobacco products.

The staff report identifies Police Department retail inspections as the means of enforcing such a provision if it were added.

7. Prohibiting delivery and online sales

The proposed ordinance does not prohibit tobacco retailers from selling products through delivery or online transactions.

Staff said this would require an additional provision in the municipal code.

Enforcement costs and inspections

The staff report also raises questions about the resources needed to administer the licensing program.

Fullerton’s Police Department currently conducts tobacco enforcement operations through a California Department of Justice grant. The department conducts approximately 160 retail inspections, eight undercover operations and 160 minor-decoy operations annually, according to the report.

The proposed ordinance would require at least one annual compliance inspection for each licensed retailer.

Staff estimates that the Police Department’s eight annual retail compliance inspections would satisfy this requirement, provided the inspections reach every licensed retailer.

The report distinguishes these compliance inspections from the department’s other enforcement activities.

The estimated $160,000 annual cost of undercover and minor-decoy operations would continue to be funded through the state grant. Those expenses would not be included in the tobacco retail licensing fees.

The city would divide program responsibilities between the Police Department and Community and Economic Development. Police would conduct compliance inspections, investigate violations and seize unlawful products. Community and Economic Development would process licenses, review zoning compliance and administer fines, suspensions and revocations.

Licensing fees remain undetermined

The ordinance authorizes the city to establish application, renewal and annual licensing fees, but does not set specific amounts.

The staff report says fees must be limited to the reasonable costs of administering the program, including business registration, planning review, enforcement and compliance inspections.

The report lists fees charged by other cities for comparison:

  • Pasadena: $681 annual retailer fee and $224 inspection fee.
  • Anaheim: $868 permit fee.
  • Orange: $880 permit fee.
  • Buena Park: $495 application fee and $275 annual renewal fee.
  • Sacramento: $550.80 application fee and $507.60 renewal fee.
  • Pico Rivera: $521.60 annual fee.
  • Los Angeles: $437 annual fee.

These amounts are not proposed Fullerton fees. The city must complete its cost analysis and bring a separate fee resolution to a noticed public hearing.

Existing tobacco retailers would have one year from the ordinance’s effective date to obtain licenses. The city must establish the fees before issuing licenses.

Planning Commission did not recommend the additional provisions

The staff report documents the Planning Commission’s consideration of the proposed regulations in August 2025.

The commission recommended the zoning amendments and tobacco retail licensing provisions, but did not recommend the additional policy considerations listed in the November 2026 staff report.

The city notified 24 tobacco retail stores during the zoning amendment process. According to staff, none provided comments.

The City Council could introduce the ordinance as presented or direct staff to incorporate additional requirements. Adding zoning or land-use changes would require further Planning Commission review.

The council’s November 17 vote introduced the ordinance for first reading. The additional restrictions remain outside the proposed ordinance unless the city returns with amendments.

The separate licensing-fee hearing will determine the costs retailers will pay to participate in the new program.


Discover more from Fullerton Observer

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Engage in civil discussion

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.