Local News

Judge Rules Officers Fired over Kelly Thomas’ Death May Not Have Their Jobs Back

Two former Fullerton police officers, Jay Cicinelli and Joseph Wolfe, who were fired over their involvement in the beating death of Kelly Thomas have been denied their jobs back, according to an October 26 ruling from Judge David A. Hoffer of the OC Superior Court.

Joseph Wolfe and Jay Cicinelli

The 2011 death of Kelly Thomas, who was homeless, at the hands of Fullerton police, which was captured on a City camera, ignited protests in Fullerton and beyond and touched off a decade-­long legal odyssey, including criminal prosecutions, civil lawsuits, and employment actions.

On July 6 and 19, 2012, respectively, former Fullerton police chief Dan Hughes fired Wolfe and Cicinelli for excessive use of force and numerous department violations.

Cicinelli was charged and ultimately acquitted of involuntary manslaughter and excessive use of force in 2013. After the verdicts, the District Attorney’s office announced that it would not proceed with Wolfe’s trial.

After the trial, Wolfe and Cicinelli sought administrative review of their firing, and after lengthy administrative hearings, the Fullerton City Council voted in 2017 to uphold Hughes’ decision to fire these employees, citing excessive force and violation of department policies.

Following this decision, both Wolfe and Cicinelli sued the city of Fullerton alleging that Fullerton City Council had been unconstitutionally biased against them.

Judge Hoffer’s ruling upheld Fullerton City Council’s decision ensuring that Cicinelli and Wolfe will not be working for the Fullerton Police Department.

“The court denies both petitions (including the portion of Wolfe’s petition seeking back pay for the time between Wolfe’s dismissal by the FPD and the City Council hearing) and confirms the City Council’s dismissal of both petitioners,” Judge Hoffer wrote in his ruling.

Protect local journalism – please subscribe to the print edition of the Fullerton Observer. Our online edition is free, but we depend on print subscriptions from readers.  Annual subscription is only $35/year. It only takes a minute – Click Here To Subscribe. Thank you for your support for the Fullerton Observer. Click here to view a copy of the print edition.

4 replies »

  1. And yet Fullerton has learned nothing from this experience. Shame on ALL of the corrupt city leaders, same as it ever was…

    And to cicinelli and Ramos?……..you didn’t get what you deserved, consider yourselves extremely lucky. Karma is headed your way, be sure your sins will find you out.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.